Monday, July 25, 2016

Chromatik vs. SmartMusic

          Chromatik is an online program for musicians that is designed to help them practice, perform and share music. It can be used on Web, Android, iOS, and Amazon devices and there are not currently any options to print or download music. It offers a free catalogue of  reference tracks, annotation tools, and recording options. The basic version is free, but there are frequent ads that are of minor annoyance, and one only has access to three “plays” or pieces of sheet music per day. There is an option to upgrade to Chromatic Pro, which allows for an ad-free experience and unlimited access to their music. If you are unable to find a piece of music, you can make a request for that piece, although there is already a variety of music styles already available for many different instruments. There are lead sheets with lyrics and chords, guitar tabs with intro-to-guitar information, as well as easy versions of pieces for beginners. There is an option to find scales, but this was sub-par. For example, the “advanced” piano scales included no bass clef and included no fingering, but these could be annotated. Perhaps the greatest advantage of this program is that students can record and share their music with others and receive feedback. One weakness is that there are not many help features. Fortunately, navigating the website is fairly intuitive. For example, if you are looking for classical music to play, you can click “Classical”, and then select your instrument. Below is a link to piano classics.

https://www.chromatik.com/piano

          SmartMusic is another online sheet music library with many other features. It is larger than that of Chromatic, and it is geared more specifically to music educators and their students. Students can play a piece of music in context of the ensemble with professional accompaniments. They receive immediate feedback as the program lets students know of pitch or rhythmic inaccuracies, which will inevitably save time in lessons. In addition, students can record themselves for their teachers who can listen to the performance on a mobile device or computer and give feedback. Students can send recordings of their performances to family and friends. Portfolios can be created of individual students performances, and there are other options for music educators like assignments and assessments and rubrics, that can be tailored for specific instruments and students. In addition, there are many exercises including scales, intervals, arpeggios, vocalises, and more. There are also practice tools such as a metronome, tuner, on-screen piano, and digital recorder. There are online training classes that users can take for a fee that will help them navigate the program. There is a free trial for educators, and there is an annual fee for students and music educators. See the "Discover SmartMusic" video at the link below for more information. 

http://www.smartmusic.com/


          Both of these programs have implications for music education. Chromatic is seems to be geared for more informal study that motivates students. Being able to access the library for free is also a benefit of Chromatic. SmartMusic, while requiring an annual subscription fee,  is tailored more specifically for music educators with its capacity for creating assignments, assessments, and for grading performances. Its ability to helps students recognize their own errors without assistance from the teacher is of enormous benefit and has the potential to save a great amount of time in lessons and large group ensmebles, freeing the director to focus on other aspects of musicianship. 

No comments:

Post a Comment